Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Necessarily Anon Faculty in a Red State's avatar

    I never met Alan, sadly, but his work leading the charge in making philosophy of sex “a thing” in contemporary…

  2. Paul Russell's avatar
  3. Facundo Bey's avatar
  4. Jane Byford's avatar
  5. Allen Hazen's avatar

    I taught in the philosophy department (“mental and moral sciences – philosophy”) at TCD in 1977-1979, and so had David…

  6. Brad's avatar
  7. An MA student's avatar

Reason and Rhetoric, Again

When someone made the banal observation that changing views via rational persuasion rarely happens, there was much clucking of blogospheric tongues.  And then along comes this:

According to Lakoff, Democrats have been wrong to assume that people are rational actors who make their decisions based on facts; in reality, he says, cognitive science has proved that all of us are programmed to respond to the frames that have been embedded deep in our unconscious minds, and if the facts don’t fit the frame, our brains simply reject them. Lakoff explained to me that the frames in our brains can be ”activated” by the right combination of words and imagery, and only then, once the brain has been unlocked, can we process the facts being thrown at us.

I confess to being agnostic about Lakoff’s claims about what "cognitive science has proved."

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Designed with WordPress