Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Daniel Kaufman's avatar
  2. AG Tanyi's avatar
  3. Noah Gordon's avatar
  4. Roger of Invisible America's avatar
  5. Luis Marxuach's avatar
  6. David Velleman's avatar
  7. Will Schofield's avatar

Finalizing Faculty Lists for Ranking Studies for 07-08

MOVING TO FRONT

Over the summer, I plan to carry out a new citation study, and in the fall, we may (finally) undertake a new on-line reputational survey.  To that end, we’ve compiled draft lists of faculty for 49 law schools that appear likely to rank in the top 35-40 by these different measures.  We may add a few more faculties to the mix, especially for purposes of a reputational survey.  The faculty lists include only academic faculty (an effort has been made to exclude clinical, adjunct, and legal writing faculty, since these studies will focus on scholarly output).  The ranking study will be per capita across the whole faculty, since many have worried that by looking only at the top quarter of the faculty in the past produced distorted results because of one or two very highly cited faculty at certain schools (e.g., Chemerinsky at Duke, or Delgado at Pittsburgh).  The draft faculty list is here:  Download law_faculty_lists_0708.rtfPlease read the introductory paragraph explaining the criteria for inclusion in the list.  I invite faculty members at the schools in question to post corrections in the comments section below.  You must post under your name with a verifiable e-mail address and, again, post only about your own school.  Corrections would include things like faculty who are retiring or leaving, and so won’t be teaching in 2007-08; new hires for 2007-08 not already included on the lists; the mistaken inclusion of clinical or adjunct faculty or the mistaken omission of regular academic faculty; and so on.  Please post only once, and be patient, as comments may take awhile to appear.  Thank you for your assistance.

Note:  the 49 faculties listed are:  Arizona, Arizona State, Berkeley, Boston Coll, Brooklyn, BU, Cardozo, Chicago, Chicago-Kent, Colorado, Columbia, Cornell, Duke, Emory, Florida, Florida State, Fordham, George Mason, Georgetown, George Washington, Harvard, Indiana, Illinois, Iowa, Michigan, Minnesota, North Carolina, Northwestern, Notre Dame, NYU, Ohio State, Penn, Pittsburgh, Rutgers-Camden, Rutgers-Newark, San Diego, Southern Cal, Stanford, Texas, UC Davis, UC Hastings, UCLA, Vanderbilt, Virginia, Washington & Lee, Wash U/St. Louis, William & Mary, Wisconsin, Yale.

UPDATE:  Do NOT e-mail me the corrections, post them in the comments please!  This way it will be a matter of public record what the corrections are, and I won’t get multiple e-mails on the same point.  All changes, if they are to be incorporated, need to be posted here.  Thank you all very much for your help.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

79 responses to “Finalizing Faculty Lists for Ranking Studies for 07-08”

  1. Lisa R. Pruitt

    Regarding UC Davis, Martha S. West. Bruce A. Wolk, and George Grossman will all retire effective 1 July 2007.

  2. Bernard W.Bell

    Please note these Rutgers Law School – Newark corrections and comments:
    Remove Suzanne Goldberg, she has moved to Columbia to head a clinic
    Add Suzanne A. Kim, who has joined the faculty from a non-tenured or tenure track position
    Correct the spelling of Anna Gelpern (not Gelperin)
    Charles Davenport should be listed as in “phased retirement”
    Charles Jones should be listed as in “phased retirement”
    Despite the fact that they are visiting at other schools next year, Sherry F. Colb and Claire Moore Dickerson should continue to be counted as members of our faculty

  3. Robert B. Ahdieh

    By way of response to Brian’s question, Victoria Nourse will be moving to Emory in January. Also, Kimberly Jenkins is now Kimberly Jenkins Robinson.

  4. Richard Delgado

    Please correct your spelling for Jean Stefancic. (You have it spelled Stefanic). Please note, as well, that although her title is Research Professor of Law & Derrick Bell Fellow at the University of Pittsburgh School of Law, she is a member of the teaching faculty and teaches regularly.

  5. In addition to Renee Jones, which I belive you know about:
    Bill Andrews and Bernie Wolfman retired from the faculty this month.
    Harry S. (Terry) Martin is our librarian.
    John Mansfield is on half-time status.

  6. Christine A. Klein

    RE: University of Florida
    Delete:
    Cally Jordan
    Andrea M. Matwyshyn
    C. Douglas Miller
    James C. Nicholas
    Michael A. Oberst
    David M. Richardson
    Mary Poe Twitchell
    Add:
    Leonard Riskin
    Katheryn Russell-Brown
    Visiting Professors:
    Ulrich Loewenheim
    Affiliated Faculty:
    Elizabeth Dale
    Correct:
    Michael K. Friel (not Friels)
    Diane H. Mazur (Not Diana)
    Thank you,
    Christine A. Klein
    Associate Dean for Faculty Development and
    Professor of Law

  7. Armen Adzhemyan

    Re Berkeley, it’s Erin Murphy, not Eric.

  8. Dear Brian:
    Many thanks for this great blog. I read your Georgetown University Law Center list to try to help. Here are a few suggested alterations:
    1. Clinical Faculty. You have a number of our full-time clinical faculty on your list. As I understand it, you are omitting them from your count. Our clinical faculty is terrific, and publishes a lot (and their exclusion may very well hurt our numbers), but to the extent you are excluding clinicians in your study then you will want to exclude:
    Jane Aiken
    Hope Babcock
    Angela Campbell
    David Koplow
    Phil Schrag
    Robert Stumberg
    David Vladeck
    2. Legal Writing Instructor. Again, I think you are excluding them:
    Dianna Donahoe
    3. New Professors
    Adam Levitin and Alvaro Santos – not sure it would make sense to include people who haven’t even started teaching yet.
    4. Left Faculty altogether
    Laura Macklin
    Kevin Quinn
    5. On leave
    Eleanor Holmes Norton has been on leave, I believe, since I joined this faculty. I’m not sure it makes sense to include someone who has been on leave that long, but again, that’s your call.
    Anyway, I hope this helps.
    Neal

  9. How do you plan to count part-time faculty, regular on-going visitors, judges, and affiliated faculty both in terms of citation count and in determining the mean? Will you count them all 1/2 as you did the part-time faculty in 2005? Do these folks then count as 1/2 in determining the mean?

  10. For SDOCCOL at ASU:
    My name is spelled Chodorow.
    Also, we have hired Carissa Hessick, who is currently a Climenko Fellow at Harvard and will start in the Fall, teaching criminal law, among other things.
    Thank you.

  11. Kathryn Hendley

    Re Wisconsin:
    I write to clarify the Nourse situation. While it is true that Nourse will be teaching at Emory in Spring 08, this does not mark her permanent departure from Wisconsin. She will not be resigning from Wisconsin. Thus, she would seem to fit your definition of part-time faculty, in that she will be holding positions at 2 law schools.
    I had asked that you include 3 faculty listed as emeritus because they are still teaching a 50% load. Perhaps their continuing teaching and service obligations are not relevant, but they continue to be active members of the faculty. These 3 are: Thain, Trubek, & Tuerkheimer.

  12. In re Rutgers-Newark: 1) Gelperin –> Gelpern; 2) Charles Davenport and Charles Jones are retiring and won’t be teaching for the full academic year; 3) will you be counting Carol Roehrenbeck as head of the library?; 4) will you be counting Jon Dubin as head of the clinics (though he has an academic post)?

  13. george schatzki

    Brian,
    The following people who are listed with the Sandra Day O’Connor College of Law at ASU teach part-time for a variety of reasons:
    Paul Bender
    Sanford Guerin
    Alan Matheson
    Ralph Spritzer
    Ann Stanton
    Michael White
    In addition, Gary Lowenthal has retired.
    Best,
    George Schatzki
    Dean of the Faculty

  14. Re: UCLA. Richard Saver is not a member of our faculty.

  15. Washington & Lee updates/corrections:
    Dennis J. Brion should be Denis J. Brion
    Mark E. Rush should be listed as “affliated” (political science/commerce) not regular faculty
    James M. Phemister has been in phased retirement (only teaching half-time)
    Lawton M. Cummings is brand-new to teaching this year after being in practice(as someone noted in an earlier comment, I wasn’t sure if you meant to include people who had not taught at all during the citation check period)
    Christopher J. Whelan should be added as part-time (will be teaching regularly every spring)
    Please remove: Montre U. Carodine, David Zaring, Donald Smythe

  16. Please note the following corrections to Colorado’s Listing:
    1. David Hill is retiring
    2. Allison Eid has resigned to join the bench of the Colorado Supreme Court
    3. Sienho Yee has resigned to return to teaching in China
    All will be missed.
    Dayna Bowen Matthew
    Professor and Associate Dean of Academic Affairs
    University of Colorado
    401 UCB – Wolf Law Building
    Boulder, Colorado 80309

  17. Additional correction to list for Washington and Lee:
    The list should include Kevin M. Crotty as an “affiliated” member of the faculty.

  18. Two final changes for Cardozo. First, in my previous comment I gave Richard Bierschbach’s first name as “Rick”; for your purposes, of course, he should be Richard.
    Second, the lateral move I had mentioned before is now completely official: Michelle Adams is leaving Seton Hall and joining the Cardozo faculty, effective this summer.
    Thanks,
    Michael

  19. Here is some additional information Fordham:
    The following professors should be removed from the list:
    Ernest E. Phillips: retired
    Russell Robinson: no longer here (at UCLA)
    Kimari Paul Emile is a misspelling. Her name is Kimani Paul Emile.
    The following regular, on-going visitors should be added:
    Abraham Bell (one semester each year)
    The following tenured faculty teach primarily in our clinic. Some are included in the proposed list, while others are not.
    James A. Cohen (not included in the proposed list)
    Elizabeth B. Cooper (included in the proposed list)
    Ian Weinstein (included in the proposed list)
    Rachel Vorspan (not included in the proposed list) is a tenured professor whose principal responsibility is direction of Fordham’s Legal Writing program.
    Finally, Professor Michael T. Madison is on phased retirement, and is at the Law School only ½ time.
    I hope this helps,
    Matt Diller
    Associate Dean for Academic Affairs
    Fordham Law School

  20. The following should be listed as part-time faculty at the University of Iowa College of Law:
    N. William Hines
    Nicholas Johnson
    Mark Schantz
    Thank you,
    Julie Kramer
    Assistant to the Dean
    The University of Iowa
    College of Law

  21. You have Andrei Marmor listed as a part-time faculty member. I think that he should be listed as full time. He is tenured in the law school, and does not teach at any other university.
    Scott Altman

  22. It was my understanding that Marmor was only in residence one semester per year, is that no longer correct? Thanks.

  23. In reply to an earlier post, you have correctly listed Jon Dubin and Carol Roehrenbeck as tenured faculty members at Rutgers-Newark. While Jon Dubin is Clinic Director, he is a tenured professor based, in large part, of his scholarship. Though Carol Roehrenbeck is the head of our library, she too is a tenured professor based, in large part, on her scholarship.

  24. Alex Aleinikoff

    Brian:
    Although you state that you are excluding clinical faculty because your study “will focus on scholarly output,” I think it would more sensible to include those clinical faculty who are tenured or are in tenure-track positions.
    At Georgetown, a single tenure standard applies to clinical and non-clinical faculty. Accordingly, I suggest you include the following clinicians:
    Jane Aiken
    Hope Babcock
    Angela Campbell
    Deborah Epstein
    Chai Feldblum
    Kristin Henning
    David Koplow
    Wallace Mlyniec
    Susan Ross
    Philip Schrag
    Abbe Smith
    David Vladeck

Designed with WordPress