Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Claudio's avatar

    I teach both large courses, like Jurisprudence and Critical Legal Thinking (a.k.a Legal Argumentation), and small seminar-based courses at Edinburgh…

  2. Charles Pigden's avatar

    Surely there is an answer to the problem of AI cheating which averts the existential threat. . It’s not great,…

  3. Mark's avatar

    I’d like to pose a question. Let’s be pessimistic for the moment, and assume AI *does* destroy the university, at…

  4. A in the UK's avatar
  5. Jonathan Turner's avatar

    I agree with all of this. The threat is really that stark. The only solution is indeed in-class essay exams,…

  6. Craig Duncan's avatar
  7. Ludovic's avatar

    My big problem with LLMs at the present time, apart from being potentially the epitome of Foucault’s panopticon & Big…

Has Anyone Ever Met a Lawyer or Judge Who Had Received (Let Alone Filled Out) a U.S. News Reputational Survey?

Brian Leiter

I was talking the other day to an experienced law school Dean, who has been asking lawyers and judges this question–have you ever received a U.S. News survey?–for a number of years, and all over the country, and s/he has yet to meet anyone who had actually received such a survey.  We know the response rate to this survey is low–always less than 30%–and, indeed, it is so low that to avoid wild fluctuations in results, U.S. News is now averaging scores for two years in this category.  So question:  has anyone ever met an attorney or jurist who has actually filled out one of these surveys?  Comments open; you must include a real e-mail address (it won't appear), even if you don't want to sign your full name.

Leave a Reply to Anthony Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

3 responses to “Has Anyone Ever Met a Lawyer or Judge Who Had Received (Let Alone Filled Out) a U.S. News Reputational Survey?”

  1. Jared

    I, too, have never met an attorney or judge who has ever admitted to filling out one of the surveys. Like you, I believe U.S. News to be so flawed and misleading, it’s scandalous, given its influence on admissions and school “reputations.” What’s needed, in my view, is a competing comprehensive set of rankings published by another major and better respected news-magazine. Even if an amalgam of rankings measures is flawed in your view, only a comprehensive and seemingly authoritative competing set of rankings (though one based on better indicia) would reduce the influence of U.S. News.

    Reply
  2. david

    yes I have, and he told me he had no idea why it was sent to him or why it would be important to participate, so he threw it out.

    Reply
  3. Anthony

    I’ve been practicing since 2006 and have never received a survey. Many of my friends are attorneys: not one has received the survey.

    Reply

Designed with WordPress