Each had a rounded mean score of 4.0; they are (with median and mode in parentheses):

City University of New York Graduate Center (4.5, 4)

New York University (4, 4)

Rutgers University, New Brunswick (4.5, 5)

University of Arizona (4, 4.25)

Washington University, St. Louis (4, 4.5)

Evaluators:  Murat Aydede, Jose Bermudez, Ned Block, David Braddon-Mitchell, Peter Carruthers, David Chalmers, Jonathan Cohen, Tim Crane, John Doris, Owen Flanagan, Tamar Gendler, Alvin Goldman, Paul Griffiths, David Hilbert, Anne Jacobson, Patricia Kitcher, Stephen Laurence, Peter Ludlow, Edouard Machery, Ronald Mallon, Jennifer Nagel, David Papineau, Walter Sinnott-Armstrong, Stephen Stich, Michael Strevens, Michael Tye, Robert Wilson.