Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. V. Alan White's avatar

    I’m a lifelong APA member with APA emeritus status. I see many reasons for the online conference, and perhaps the…

  2. Colin Marshall's avatar

    Thanks for this, Matt – a good point. In scheduling the Pacific APA, Alex Sager and I did what I…

  3. Matt Lister's avatar

    “But, on the other hand, a virtual APA is in principle available to philosophers around the world” This is often…

  4. Kian Mintz-Woo's avatar

    Just a quick note to say that I thought these points were really well-taken. I registered for this year’s APA…

  5. LFC's avatar

    You’re right, that’s my mistake. Because the two incidents occurred a couple of months apart, I guess they often get…

  6. EAS's avatar

    This is incorrect. The incident involving Petrov occured on September 26, 1983. Petrov judged that the Oko early warning system’s…

  7. Gwen Bradford's avatar

“International Journal Network”–another “scam”?

A graduate student in philosophy writes:

I recently received an email invitation to be on the editorial board or serve as an associate editor for an open access journal run by the International Journal Network (http://www.journalnetwork.org). While I’m flattered by the invitation, it also raised a number of red flags. For one, I’m a (very young) graduate student, and an invitation to serve in either of these positions at a journal is unusual. The invitation also included this line: “In either position, you can participate as little or as much as you like.” More importantly, a quick review of the organization reveals it has 325 journals (including, for example, the “International Journal of Paranormal Investigation,” the “International Journal of Astrology,” and the “International Journal of Religious Mysteries”). Most bizarre is that they seem willing to accept submissions now for a number of journals that apparently have no previous editions published and no boards or editors in place. For all the journals I looked at closely, the required submission fee is $125 per article.

I’ve already rejected the offer since, as a young graduate student, I don’t feel comfortable in those roles at any journal. But I wonder if the International Journal Network is worth further scrutiny.

Any other readers familiar with this operation?

Leave a Reply to Ben Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

4 responses to ““International Journal Network”–another “scam”?”

  1. Their review process is interesting, to say the least:

    "In stage 1, the paper is either accepted or rejected by the managing editorial team, usually within a week. If the article is accepted, it is published immediately in the journal.

    In stage 2, the journal's associate editors are notified of the publication, and can provide additional public reviews of the paper. Associate editors must apply to the role, and provide a detailed curriculum vitae to indicate their qualifications in reviewing the paper. Authors are encouraged to upload revised manuscripts based on the reviews of the associate editors."

    Sounds like "Accept first, maybe review later."

  2. Librarian Jeffrey Beall has a post about the publisher on his Scholarly Open Access blog and concludes:

    "This publisher appears to be a one-man operation that operates out of an apartment in Baltimore. No serious scholar should submit his or her work to this publisher."

    http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/06/11/oa-publisher-launches-with-over-350-new-journals/#more-1772

  3. It's a scam, at least according to Geoffrey Beall at the Scholarly Open Access blog: "This publisher appears to be a one-man operation that operates out of an apartment in Baltimore. No serious scholar should submit his or her work to this publisher."

    The full list of journals from this scam artist is astonishing (and a bit hilarious).

    http://scholarlyoa.com/2013/06/11/oa-publisher-launches-with-over-350-new-journals/#more-1772

Designed with WordPress