The schools are ranked in peer groups by their rounded mean score to .5 intervals; after a school's name appears the median and mode scores.  Where the median and mode scores are higher than the rounded mean that usually indicates that a minority of evaluators scored the program a bit more lowly than others.

Group 1 (1) (rounded mean of 4.5)

University of Chicago (4.5, 5)

Group 2 (2-5) (rounded mean of 4.0)

Brown University (4, 4)

Columbia University (4, 4)

New York University (4, 4)

University of California, Riverside (4.25, 4.5)

Evaluators:  Anne Margaret Baxley, Jessica Berry, Lee Braver, Thomas Carson, Maudemarie Clark, David Dudrick, Stephen Houlgate, Andrew Huddleston, Peter Kail, Paul Katsafanas, Pierre Keller, Michelle Kosch, Brian Leiter, Yitshak Melamed, Brian O’Connor, Peter Poellner, Mathias Risse, Michael Rosen, Iain Thomson, Eric Watkins, Robert Wicks, Allen Wood.