Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Keefe Bella's avatar

    “Though not outright proof on its face” is where the heuristics from the conversation would inform next steps. Plagiarism of…

  2. AG Tanyi's avatar

    I can’t speak to what LLMs and AI in general might be capable of now or in the future. What…

  3. Matteo Bianchetti's avatar
  4. Keith Douglas's avatar

    “said explicitly that AI will simply accelerate something that is already happening.” – The metaphor people use is “force multiplier”…

  5. sahpa's avatar

    (Sorry, I feel I’m becoming the gadfly in this conversation!) Regarding 1: I learned to take the ‘demographics is destiny’…

  6. sahpa's avatar

    Yeah, I clocked this one right away as almost surely AI. Given the username, I should allow that it *might*…

  7. sahpa's avatar

    Apologies if I’m reading you uncharitably, but it sounds like you are advocating for course failure and later expulsion on…

The first five laws of cyber-dynamics

First Law of Cyber-dynamics:  any unmoderated comment thread will reduce the total amount of knowledge and understanding in the world in proportion to its length.

Second Law of Cyber-dynamics:  any unmoderated comment thread on a post touching on politics, race or gender will degenerate into vile idiocy within the first ten comments.

Third Law of Cyber-dynamics:  no off-hand comment is too trivial to not generate thousands of words of cyber-commentary.

Fourth Law of Cyber-dynamics:  no off-hand comment is too benign to fail to generate offense somewhere else in cyberspace.

Fifth Law of Cyber-dynamics:  any comment thread on a blog with an ideological identity will give expression to the most extreme version of that identity within the first ten comments.  (The Law of Cyber-Group Polarizaton–Brit will be shedding some light on this next week).

,

One response to “The first five laws of cyber-dynamics”

  1. […] features of an unmoderated comment thread on a blog or anywhere else in cyberspace, and so all the laws of cyber-dynamics apply.  “Condescension from below” is the primary form of expression for the average […]

Designed with WordPress