So with results from our two earlier polls (both of which got over 500 votes each), here are the "top 20"; where the vote differential between one journal and the journal ahead of it were substantial, I insert a line in between; where there is no line, it means the vote differences were relatively small.

1.  Philosophical Review

===================

2.  Nous

====================

3.  Journal of Philosophy

4.  Mind

=====================

5.  Philosophy & Phenomenological Research

=====================

6.  Australasian Journal of Philosophy

7.  Philosophical Studies

8.  Philosopher's Imprint

======================

9.  Philosophical Quarterly

10. Analysis

=======================

11. Synthese

=======================

12.  Erkenntnis

13.  Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society

14.  Canadian Journal of Philosophy

15.  American Philosophical Quarterly

16.  European Journal of Philosophy

17.  Pacific Philosophical Quarterly

=========================

18.  Ratio

==========================

19.  Ergo

==========================

20.  Philosophical Perspectives

Runner-up:  Dialectica (trailing #20 by just four votes)