Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Messina's avatar
  2. David Wallace's avatar
  3. Phil Bold's avatar
  4. Brian Garrett's avatar
  5. The Pacific's avatar
  6. Craig Duncan's avatar

    One provocative read (if you can get past the sensationalistic headline) is econ blogger Noah Smith’s substack post from last…

  7. Moussa's avatar

On the pursuit of “novelty” in jurisprudence and normative philosophy

Les Green (Oxford) comments:

In my own fields, the pursuit of novelty has bad effects: one can be pretty sure that the next general theory of law will be more daft than the last one. And in moral and political philosophy writers continually ‘discover’ principles that no one in the history of humanity ever heard of.

The novelty-fetish has further  knock-on effects.   It isn’t enough for ideas to be new; others need to acknowledge that they are new, so small novelties get over-emphasised, and the errors of past writers exaggerated. No longer are others merely mistaken, misguided, or muddled—their claims must be ‘ridiculous’, ‘disgraceful’, or ‘ludicrous’. These epithets have various meanings, but they have a common use. They are all ways of pleading, ‘Don’t read him! Read me, me, ME!’

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Designed with WordPress