Following up on this post, and once again taking account of faculty changes since the fall 2014 PGR, here's an attempted update of the top (3.5 or higher) programs in metaphysics for 2016-17, again by rough "clusters" of peer programs:

Group 1 (1-2)

New York University

Rutgers University, New Brunswick

Group 2 (3-7)

Massachussetts Institute of Technology

Oxford University

Princeton University

University of Notre Dame

University of Southern California

Group 3 (8-17)

Cornell University

Syracuse University

University of Arizona

University of California, Berkeley

University of California, Santa Barbara

University of Massachussetts, Amherst

University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (this assumes that L.A. Paul stays)

University of St. Andrews/University of Stirling Joint Program

University of Toronto

University of Virginia