Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Ex-Academic's avatar
  2. Brian Leiter's avatar
  3. Anon Faculty Member's avatar
  4. DH's avatar

    As an international student, I honestly don’t know how good an indicator the GRE is, at least for students whose…

  5. Cameron Buckner's avatar
  6. Herbert Hart's avatar

    This might filter out intelligent neurodivergent students who struggle with timed admissions tests.

  7. Mark J Engleson's avatar

    When jt comes to students’ ability to do advanced logic, the math section of the GRE is more valuable than…

A new biography of Habermas

The intellectual historian Peter Gordon (Harvard) offers an informative review of the new biography of Habermas.  Among other things, I was struck by the irony that Habermas–always an admirable critic of post-Nazi complacency in Germany, as Gordon emphasizes–secured his habilitation and first academic post thanks to the influence of the disgusting Nazi and lifelong anti-semite Gadamer!  (I wonder if Habermas knew?  For a long time, Gadamer was quite good at keeping it under wraps.)  Gordon, in my view, significantly overstates Habermas's philosophical importance (in contrast to his invaluable role as a public intellectual holding post-War Germany to moral account).  When Marxism returns, as it no doubt will, in something more like Marx's form, Habermas will be remembered mainly as taking the philosophically feeble (and irrelevant) attack on instrumental reason that began with Horkheimer and expanding it to the point that so-called "Critical Theory" collapsed into precisely the kind of bourgeois moral theorizing Marx loathed.  (For anyone interested, I discuss this in a bit more detail here.)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Designed with WordPress