Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. André Hampshire's avatar

    Sagar’s claim that LLMs pose an “existential threat” to universities rests on a set of conflations that do not survive…

  2. Edwin Fruehwald's avatar

    Generative AI has the potential to do catastrophic harm to higher education. This is because learning is a biological process…

  3. Anonymous1's avatar

    When the problem of AI-based papers started a few years ago, I immediately switched to in-class essay exams and told…

  4. V. Alan White's avatar
  5. Kenneth Pike's avatar

    In terms of pedagogy, I agree with Professor Sagar. In philosophy courses, at least, the exercise is the point; I…

  6. AG Tanyi's avatar

    The central claim is that LLMs (or AI more generally, I suppose) is an existential threat to universities. This gets…

The “nightmare” of UK academic life, redux?

From a letter to the editor of The Guardian by philosopher James Ladyman (Bristol):

Most of our highly paid deans and pro-vice-chancellors have not conducted an undergraduate tutorial in years, and many more highly paid staff neither teach students nor carry out academic research. Deans, heads of department and promotion committees were elected, but now they are appointed from above.

Teaching is often hourly paid. Decision-making is centralised and remote from both the academic and administrative staff who interact with students, so policies to improve efficiency cause disruption and waste. Student fees are being spent on consultations and surveys, and the generation of benchmarks and targets.

Countless documents record strategic visions no poet would immortalise. The corridors echo with the banal hyperbole of public relations. Our cathedrals of learning worship metrics that do not measure anything of value.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Designed with WordPress