Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Daniel Kaufman's avatar
  2. AG Tanyi's avatar
  3. Noah Gordon's avatar
  4. Roger of Invisible America's avatar
  5. Luis Marxuach's avatar
  6. David Velleman's avatar
  7. Will Schofield's avatar

An Open Letter to Other Law Bloggers Regarding the US News.com Rankings

MOVING TO FRONT, SINCE IT IS THAT TIME OF YEAR (BLOG EMPEROR CARON:  I'M LOOKING AT YOU!)

When the new rankings come out shortly, may I suggest that you not post the overall ranking.  You all know the overall rank assigned to a school by U.S. News is meaningless, often perniciously so.  It combines too many factors, in an inexplicable formula, and much of the underlying data isn't reliable, and some of it (e.g., expenditures on secretarial salaries and electriciy) isn't even relevant.  You all know this.  So don't report it.  The fact that this garbage appears in what used to be a major 'news' magazine doesn't change the fact that it is garbage. 

Instead, let me suggest that if you want to blog about the rankings when they come out, write about some of the underlying data that speaks for itself:  the reputational scores, for example, or the bar passage rates, or the numerical credentials of the students.  Those have limitations too–the median of 500 is not really comparable to the median of 200; the reputation scores are not based on presenting evaluators with any information about the schools being evaluated; and so on–but one can at least say clearly what the limitations are, and one is not hostage either to the dishonesty of the schools "reporting" the data or the sheer idiocy of the U.S. News ranking formula.

APRIL 9, 2009 ADDENDUM:  I should also note that, to my knowledge, U.S. News has done nothing to address the methodological problems raised last year.

UPDATE (MARCH 5, 2013):  The Dean of a flagship state law school writes, "Your post on US News Rankings is much appreciated. Schools like mine do not play the game, and truly try to keep our tuition low.  We spend our money on our students and their education. The hypocrisy of the 'legal education reformers' astounds me. They will be the first to denigrate the education we offer here, since we are not a top 100 school. Thanks for the good message, even if not enough schools listen." 

UPDATE (MARCH 10, 2014):  Lawyer Bobby Cheren writes: "How about referring to them as the 'USNews.com' rankings from now on, as the magazine is essentially defunct?"  Apt point!

AND REMEMBER:  Changes in ranking do not mean anything in reality changed:  it means only that some law schools lied/fudged in their data reporting/massaging more than their competitors.

5 responses to “An Open Letter to Other Law Bloggers Regarding the US News.com Rankings”

  1. Leiter’s Open Letter to Law Bloggers

    Brian Leiter, An Open Letter to Other Law Bloggers Regarding the US News Rankings When the new rankings come out in a couple of weeks, may I suggest that you not post the overall ranking. You all know the overall rank assigned to a school by U.S. News …

  2. A Dissenting View Re: Brian Leiter’s Request That Bloggers Not Blog About U.S. News 2009 Overall Rankings When They Come Out Next Month

    On March 13, 2008, Brian Leiter posted an article entitled An Open Letter to Other Law Bloggers Regarding the US News Rankings where he requests that us bloggers do not post about the U.S. News and World Reports 2009 overall

  3. Rank Not Lest Ye Be Ranked

    Vault.com has created its own ranking of the top US law schools. Vaults blog post about it is here

  4. First Takes on US News

    I’ve been absurdly–and I do mean absurdly–busy of late. But US News is out and the feeding frenzy’s begun. (More than 1100 comments to this post at abovethelaw.com! Now that’s a feeding frenzy.) Here are some initial takes on the

  5. linx: tweet tweet!

    [cynthia foster] Good Friday isn’t the best day for news. But here’s a little. You’ll notice that it is, indeed, rankings season again. An Open Letter to Other Law Bloggers Regarding the US News Rankings (Brian Leiter’s Law School Reports)…

Designed with WordPress