Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. F.E. Guerra-Pujol's avatar

    Apropos of Sagar’s wish to foist the A.I. industry by its own petard, this article appeared in print in yesterday’s…

  2. Claudio's avatar

    I teach both large courses, like Jurisprudence and Critical Legal Thinking (a.k.a Legal Argumentation), and small seminar-based courses at Edinburgh…

  3. Charles Pigden's avatar

    Surely there is an answer to the problem of AI cheating which averts the existential threat. . It’s not great,…

  4. Mark's avatar

    I’d like to pose a question. Let’s be pessimistic for the moment, and assume AI *does* destroy the university, at…

  5. A in the UK's avatar
  6. Jonathan Turner's avatar

    I agree with all of this. The threat is really that stark. The only solution is indeed in-class essay exams,…

  7. Craig Duncan's avatar

My five favorite Americans of the 20th-century

1.  Eugene Debs.  Stalwart if unsuccessful socialist agitator for an alternative to devotion to the market.

2.  H.L. Mencken.  Merciless critic of religious, patriotic and other bullshit, with his own parochial prejudices to be sure, but a great writer who punched up, down, and sideways without apology.

3.  A. Philip Randolph. The most important labor and civil rights leader of the century, who made MLK possible, and who always championed, from the beginning, the interdependence of racial and economic progress.

4.  Franklin Delano Roosevelt.  He betrayed his class and saved America from fascism and probably saved the world from the Nazis.  The Reagan reaction of the last forty years was against his vision for social democracy.

5.  Bayard Rustin.  He organized the 1963 March on Washington, and worked with A. Philip Randolph on behalf of the same goals:  Randolph and Rustin were a team.  He did all this as a gay African-American, and in the face of enormous bigotry both within and outside the movement.  A person of enormous dignity and courage, whom I had the privilege to interview in the early 1980s.  I will never forget it.  

Your favorites?  Comments may take awhile to appear, so post only once!  But I'm curious to hear from readers and I will require you to post with your full name and valid e-mail address

Leave a Reply to s. wallerstein Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

52 responses to “My five favorite Americans of the 20th-century”

  1. 1. Sinclair Lewis – America's first and last truly great non-exceptionalist writer of fiction. (OK, Steinbeck pulled it off too – once.)
    2. John W. Campbell – Inventor of the greatest of all distinctively American art forms. (Honorable mention to Asimov.)
    3. Chuck Berry – Inventor of the OTHER greatest of all distinctively American art forms. (Dylan is maybe greater, but certainly later.)
    4. Charlotte Perkins Gilman – America's most incisive and inclusive social critic. (Nuts to Mencken! Libertarians need not apply.)
    5. Orson Welles – best representative of the doomed but heroic idea that mass culture could also be subversive. (Beats Charlie Chaplin by a nose.)

  2. I would add:
    Pete Seeger (top of my list)
    Dorothy Day
    I.F. Stone

  3. Chomsky. I don't know what we're going to do without him.

  4. Miles Davis
    MLK Jr
    Muhammad Ali
    Malcolm X
    James Baldwin

  5. My favorites are always in the arts:
    1. Fred Astaire: mon semblable–can't sing; can't act; balding
    2. John Cage: no ear for music
    3. Ornette Coleman: the men who live in the white house. love life.
    4. George Herriman: woofed with dreams
    5. Bob Dylan: what cares he for praise?

  6. Eugene Debs

    Muhammad Ali

    Martin Luther King Jr

    I choose these three for the same reason, the moral example they provide by answering to their conscience, not simply conforming to the demands of the times in which they live. They are the equals of a Gandhi, a Mandela.

    My last two choices have had a significant impact on the culture and provided keys to understanding the times (and times to come):

    William S Burroughs

    Philip K Dick

  7. 1. Sylvia Plath–brilliant implacably honest self sacrificial intellectual blood for the women's movement from the 60's forward.

    2. Jimmy Carter–the only 20th century President that was and still is truly virtuous.

    3. Martin Luther King–a true monument to progressive change, even if backlash to it persists today.

    4. Neil Armstrong–a name that will live in human history for as long as it exists, and deservedly as a brave and (for the most part as I can tell) decent person.

    5. Ruth Bader Ginsberg–the 20th century gift who keeps on giving.

  8. Five pretty significant 20th Century American women (in addition to the two(?!) mentioned so far):

    Clara Lemlich
    Jane Addams
    Jeanette Rankin
    Hedy Epstein
    Kathleen Hanna

  9. Bob Dylan
    Allen Ginsberg
    Bayard Rustin (I was in jail with him for a couple of days in 1964)
    Noam Chomsky
    Edward Said (he was a U.S. citizen)

  10. Louis Armstrong
    FDR
    Robert Moses
    MLK

  11. Joan Didion–the best English prose stylist of the twentieth century
    Mark Rothko– the best of the most significant art movement of the twentieth century
    Henry James– the best American novelist of the twentieth century
    Philip Johnson–the best American architect of the twentieth century
    Willa Cather–the best American novelist of the twentieth century whose name is not Henry James

    These opinions are objectively true, so don't try to dispute them. If I could say Joan Didion five times I just might.

  12. Debs and Rustin for sure

    Dylan, or go to the source and nominate Alan Lomax?
    Andrea Dworkin
    Carl Rogers

    I'm fascinated by the left Republican moment, but whether that's enough to make (say) Bob La Follette Sr a 'favourite' I'm not sure.

  13. Matías Vernengo

    1. Upton Sinclair
    2. Frances Perkins
    3. Michael Harrington
    4. James Baldwin
    5. Bernie Sanders (too 21st century?)

  14. Ursula Leguin
    Nora Hurston Neale

    Makes six, sorry

  15. In no particular order (top 10):

    Hunter S. Thompson
    Joan Didion
    Robert Heinlein
    Theodore Roosevelt
    George Marshall
    Neil Armstrong
    Martin Luther King
    Dwight Eisenhower
    Reinhold Niebuhr
    John Dewey
    Lionel Trilling
    Madeleine L'Engle
    Neil Simon

    BL COMMENT: You only get 5! No more cheating!

  16. I struggle mightily between Neil Simon and Sid Caeser.

  17. Agree with you completely about Didion. Also one of the most independently minded. She has managed to aggravate every political orientation at some point. I wish she could start all over again. We desperately need her to skewer the current mess of self-delusions that our politics are operating under.

  18. If a non-American may suggest just one?

    Paul Robeson, a genius in the field of the two most important social activities, music and politics, the latter at quite heroic levels.

  19. I'll second Muhammad Ali and Andrea Dworkin. John Cage. And for some weird reason, Dick Cavett. Can't think of a fifth just now.

  20. One figure, it seems to me, stands at least a full head above everyone else listed. Recently reread his best known book, *Operation Manual for Spaceship Earth* which I first encountered as an undergraduate back in the late 1970s, looking to obtain more of his works since for some reason I didn't back then. His name: R. Buckminster Fuller. A true visionary.

  21. Clarence Darrow
    John Dewey
    Barbara Jordan


    Cesar Chavez
    and one of: FDR / MLK/ RFK?…….
    or George Carlin

  22. I just want to note that I also cheated, by not putting those five names forward as my personal five favorite Americans, a category that I don't quite understand but would most likely include Rosa Parks, Rachel Carson, possibly Helen Nearing and definitely Tina Weymouth.

  23. Satchel Paige
    Chuck Berry
    Johnny Cash
    Eugene V. Debs
    Yogi Berra

  24. 1. Myles Horton. (Think global, act local)
    2. James R. Hoffa. (Break the rules to force the ruling class to change).
    3. Robert Johnson, Son House, et al. (The font of all American music)
    4. Louis Armstrong. (Indigenous American music)
    5. Brand Blanshard. (American rationalism at its best).

  25. Susan Sontag. Said some things that needed saying, when no one else dared.

  26. Excellent choices – Cather's Death Comes for the Archbishop is a masterpiece

  27. Clarence Darrow. He made defending the unpopular and despised a noble calling.

  28. Off the top of my head…

    (1) Emma Goldman (does she count as 20th and/or American..?)
    (2) Madonna
    (3) John von Neumann (does he count as an American…?)
    (4) Tallulah Bankhead
    (5) Neal Cassady

  29. Franklin D Roosevelt
    Eleanor Roosevelt
    Jane Jacobs
    Fred Hampton
    Louis Armstrong

  30. Joe Louis
    Tennessee Williams
    Aretha Franklin
    Edward Hopper
    MLK Jr.

    Honorable mention (because he was only an American citizen for the last 15 years of his life): Einstein

  31. Fred Hampton — Organizational genius. What he accomplished by 21 beggars belief. Indelible speaking ability. Of course he had to go.
    Edward Abbey — Greatest prose poet of one of the world's (and certainly America's) most glorious landscapes, and its exploration. Champion of what's wild, human and otherwise.
    Dorothea Lange — Singular achievements capturing singular moments in U.S. history. Her (at the time suppressed) documentation of Japanese internment deserves to be as well known as her work on migrant workers.
    Lowell Bennion — Personal hero from the culture I come from (Mormonism). Model of investing creative energy into uplifting others, living what's good in religion, becoming more and more subversive as one ages.
    Prince — Candidate for greatest American songwriter on range and volume alone. Add being one of the greatest multi-instrumentalists, dancers, singers, live performers, norm-busters, style innovators, creators of personae, anonymous humanitarians. Adored, ignored, understood, and misunderstood — often in the same person.

  32. It's remarkable that the only philosopher receiving mention is Dewey, and he was barely that (a few people mentioned Chomsky but I assume that's not on account of his work in linguistics or the philosophy of language).

  33. My #5 is Brand Blanshard. He isn’t usually regarded as one of the great American philosophers, but I think he was. He defended views that were already on the wane, and so he doesn’t get much attention.

  34. Charles Burnett
    Angela Davis
    Maya Deren
    Philip Guston
    Fred Hampton

  35. Jerry Garcia (Don't get me started.)
    Richard Wright (Our Dickens)
    Dr. Jonas Salk (What a relief for parents!)
    Babe Ruth (Americans love the long ball.)
    Theodore Geisel bka Dr. Seuss (Those silly books work.)

    To Mike Valdman: I thought of including philosophers, including Professor Chomsky (with whom I once had lunch) but then figured that Professor Leiter, judging from his own list, was probably looking for people in other fields of endeavor.

  36. Just to clarify, readers can list any five Americans they want, regardless of field! I certainly like Quine, and Jerry Fodor, and C.L. Stevenson and others, but they wouldn't be in my top five, despite the excellence of their work.

  37. mvwedin@ucdavis.edu

    First two (SNCC founders)I worked with back in Mississippi:
    1. Robert Parish (Bob) Moses
    2 James Forman

    Then for reasons given by Brian

    3. FDR (with Eleanor)

    For unmatched expressiveness and melancholy (a Swedish trait I've not shed)

    4. Edward Hopper

    5. Bogart because without him there would be no Casablanca and without Casablanca nothing for my desert island cinema

    6. John Berryman for the "The Dream Songs."

  38. The only two about whom I feel fanatical:

    Buster Keaton
    Brian Wilson

    To fill out the remainder:

    Roosevelt, Dewey and Roberto Clemente

  39. Inspired by others here, I'll add my fifth, poet John Ashbery, though I sense I'm doing so because he's a favorite person (or poet or artist) who happens to have been American. Still, his work looms large over the field of late 20th century American poetry. Some really terrific nominees up-thread here!

  40. Angela Davis, who is mentioned on at least one list, is a philosopher.

    BL COMMENT: Her contributions to philosophy were minimal; her contributions to more important things were not.

  41. Maybe not for a Top 5, but for a Top 10 list I'd nominate Rorty's grandfather, Walter Rauschenbusch, who was influential in the social-gospel movement, which spread to my homeland (Canada), where it motivated several leaders in the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation, precursor of the NDP. Also, Robert M. La Follette, Sr.

  42. [One of my more satisfying law school experiences was working for the attorney who was (long before, naturally) Angela Davis's attorney in the Marin Courthouse case.]

  43. To Larry Franz: It was between Clemente and Ruth.

    To BL: This turned out to be a very interesting intellectual exercise. Please allow me to explain. I actually came up with several lists as I strolled my granddaughter. Of course, if I list MY favorite 20th Century Americans, they'd ALL be philosophers: at the end of the day, that's all I really care about. But then we'd just have my Favorite 20th Century American Philosophers (and I also thought we might have been there and done that). That list, I want to say, would have been 'doubly subjective': subjective as to perspective and most outstanding individuals seen therefrom. (I also started 1 with folks like my mother and 4th grade teacher on it- obviously WAY too idiosyncratic.) So I settled on the criterion I took to be yours and others: widely known, historically important 20th century Americans whose accomplishments I thought especially noteworthy. In other words, I selected as an historically minded American sans my affinity for philosophy. What resulted, then, was 'objectively subjective': 20th Century Americans most OTHER educated Americans would have heard of whom I myself thought to be truly great at what they did. (To add further objectivity to the exercise, I was trying to recall prominent figures others here had neglected to list.) Somehow I just thought that it would be best to leave philosophy out of it, so that it would be more about being American than footnoting Plato.

  44. W.C Fields
    Linus Pauling
    Richard Feynman
    Walter Kaufmann
    James D. Watson ("D" as in DNA)

  45. 1. Noam Chomsky
    2. Hubert Harrison (lost African American intellectual in Socialist Party)
    3. Ed Roberts (pioneering disability rights advocate)
    4. Frida Zames (major figure in disability advocacy in NYC; has street named after her)
    5. Marta Russell (played major role in focusing on disability in terms of political economy, not cultural identity).

  46. Charles Schulz
    Donald Westlake
    Marlene Dietrich
    James Garner
    Fritz Leiber

    Not the best, not the greatest, just my favorites.

  47. Christopher Faille

    I'll start with two philosophers, very different from each other:

    1. John Dewey
    2. Murray Rothbard

    Proceed to two psychologists, both operating with the 'big picture' and, again, very different from each other:

    3. B.F. Skinner
    4. Erik Erikson

    Finally, my wild card —

    5. Fran Tarkenton

  48. All my heroes are free speech heroes:
    Helen Keller
    Emma Goldman
    Charlotte Anita Whitney
    Louis Brandeis
    the Warren Court

  49. I was meditating on my five choices above, Dylan, Allen Ginsberg, Rustin, Chomsky and Said and I realized that I was aware of all of them and admired them when I left the U.S. in 1977. Then I realized that your choices, Professor Leiter, are all figures from the 60's (Rustin) or earlier and that in general, people's choices generally do not come from the last third or quarter of the 20th century. Do that say something about your readers or about the decline of the U.S. as an inspiration ?

  50. This was difficult, and I left off some names I might have included (from various fields of activity) because they'd already been mentioned.

    Thurgood Marshall
    Michael Harrington
    Fred Harris (Senator; ran unsuccessfully for President, 1976)
    Robert Stone (novelist)

    And for a fifth, a tie between two film-makers/directors:
    Gus Van Sant
    Francis Ford Coppola

    —–
    KEYWORDS:
    Primary Blog

  51. […] Back in 2018–with my views and those of readers. […]

  52. Sometime ago (so I can’t remember the source), I read that Mencken was a racist until World War I. During the war, he experienced discrimination in getting published, for one thing, because he was of German descent. Learning what it was like to be on the receiving end, he abandoned his racism and became a strong advocate for Black civil rights.

Designed with WordPress