Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Richard Moore's avatar
  2. François Kammerer's avatar
  3. Mark's avatar
  4. M. El-Youssef's avatar

    For the nuts and bolts of “rudimentary forms of knowledge, their evolutionary origins…and unsophisticated social practices”, Sara Shettleworth’s incredibly detailed…

  5. Daniel Greco's avatar

    I suspect we differ on big picture questions about how correlated various different mental abilities are. I think a reasonable…

  6. Paul Canis's avatar
  7. Michel-Antoine Xhignesse's avatar

The protests in Iran

One account from NYRB; readers can supply links to others in the comments.  An excerpt:

Are the protests that were prompted by the death in police custody of a young woman, Mahsa Amini, on September 16 comparable to the strikes and demonstrations that led to the Shah’s downfall in 1979, or has Amini become a figure in the tragic mold of Mohamed Bouazizi, the Tunisian street-seller whose self-immolation in 2010 touched off the Arab Spring, a region-wide upheaval that, in the end, failed to fulfill its early promise?…

The protests that followed Amini’s death after she was arrested in Tehran by the morality police, apparently for an infraction of the Islamic dress code, started in earnest in her home province of Kurdistan, in the far northwest, and spread across the country. All the agencies of the state mobilized to meet the threat and began a nationwide campaign against the protesters, including beatings, arrests, deaths in custody, propaganda, and judicial indictments. After four weeks and an estimated two hundred deaths—casualty figures must be treated with immense caution—the protests don’t appear to be letting up. By some measures, and making allowance for our reliance on reports that protesters have managed to send out of the country despite the government’s efforts to block the Internet, they are growing….

What we’ve been seeing on our social media feeds is revolt at its most emancipatory: young women dancing around bonfires of headscarves or strutting bareheaded through the streets and shouting for the end of the Islamic Republic. Among the most remarkable of these novelties was footage showing a male official from the Ministry of Education being chased out of a girls’ school by pupils who had taken off their maghnaehs—an egregiously bureaucratic version of the Islamic headcover invented by some zealot in the early days of the revolution—and were furiously hurling plastic bottles and pieces of stationery at him. Other videos showing women that had strayed from the main body of protesters being beaten savagely by policemen—as in the Serengeti, it’s the stragglers who are pulled down—were among the most distressing. And for all the sense one gets of a generational divide, with the young people on the front line while their parents fret at home, a tender solicitude across the ages is also in evidence. “I am removing my headscarf out of respect for you,” a woman in her fifties told two bareheaded teenage girls in the Tehran district of Tajrish, to which they replied, “Thank you, Auntie.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

One response to “The protests in Iran”

  1. Dear Brian Leiter,
    I am pleased to see that the scale of Iranians protesting both in and out of Iran is at a level that has gained your attention. I, Ali Hasanzadeh, am a 2nd year Ph.D. student of Philosophy at University at Buffalo. Although I have lived in the US for the past 9 years, I consider myself an Iranian and lived in Tehran and Gorgan for the first 17 years of my life.
    First of all, I'd like to say that the stage of rebellion which my people and I at should not be seen as a series of protests, but the start of an important revolution! This started from Mahsa's death, and was followed by many more (so far the official count is over 270, 39 of whom are children under age of 15), but it is much deeper than what you think. This is the cause of 43 years of suffering under a horrifying regime of dictatorship. It is the burning flame of countless other smaller protests in the past four decades and hundreds and hundreds of men and women who were killed for believing in the right to free speech. We are not asking Islamic Republic of Iran to stop forcing women and girls to cover their heads and bodies, we are not asking them to go a bit easier on their beatings and mass murders. We want them gone; cut from the root and have every bit of power taken away from them.
    Of course, many are concerned about the group who would come to power after this revolution. This is not our concern for now, and I know how immature and idiotic that sounds, but this is a leaderless revolution and there are of course parties and groups who are hoping to rule Iran at some point. Maybe they will, and maybe they won't, that will be for the people to decide when they go to vote. That is what we want. We want our votes to matter. We do not wish for every single bit of power to be in the hands of one man. For now, Liberalist, Conservative, Socialist, Monarchist, Communist, etc. all believe that this is not what we want for our country, wish to separate religion and politics as much as possible, and hopefully allow the power to be divided among different political parties.
    As non Iranians, you can of course help us. But let me tell you why you should: This is a matter of Human Rights, Women’s Rights, International Security, and much more. But even if you do not care about these and you are not against war, child labor, and mass slaughtering, helping Iranians to earn their freedom benefits you directly: So much of your tax money goes to the U.S. military’s activities in the Middle East and the Persian Gulf due to the chaos and fear that the Islamic Republic has caused in the past 44 years. Even if that is not attractive to you, remember that helping with the succession of this movement has a direct positive effect on your daily fuel and energy cost. There are many reasons to help, and I’m sure I can convince every single one of you regardless of your values and standards. But one matter still remains and that is the “How” of this problem.
    So far, one of the most important things that we have done from here was to help Iranians in Iran to get hold of Starlink receivers and routers so that they have access to Internet. Of course this is only for a small population, but those are the ones who are leading the people on the street and have access to all the media and can send them to news organizations outside of Iran. But there is more to be done. Of course, we are not trying to have US send its military over our soil and turn into a war zone (nor would we ever want that), but here is where you come in:
    There are hundreds (if not thousands) of individuals living in US who are children and relatives of those in power in Islamic Republic regime. They live here with pockets full of money, do investments, and play the role of backup for their parents in case things get out of hand in Iran. These people are not hard to recognize by us. We know who they are and to whom they are connected to. If we can do it, it must be quite easy for the Government to have a list of all those Iranian immigrants with strong financial assets, and see where has the money came from. We want all their assets to be compensated, and them kicked out of this country for good. That money belongs to our country and we want the government figures in Iran to have another reason to fear. You can be along our side and demand this from the US government. We need your help.
    Right now Iranians over the country are demanding meeting with their senates and congressmen in order to see what they can do for them. We met earlier today with Brian Higgins' office on this matter and have more meetings scheduled with him and other political figures of Western NY.
    Let me know if you are interested, or have questions.

    These are the words of Slavoj Žižek on the second week of protests in Iran: https://youtu.be/OzT3lWpafEk

    This is not a protest. It's a Revolution, Revolution! (این دیگه اعتراض نیست. انقلابه انقلاب!)
    #MahsaAmini
    #WomenLifeFreedom

    With a hope of a free Iran,
    Ali Hasanzadeh

Designed with WordPress