Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Shane Glackin's avatar
  2. Peter M Carruthers's avatar
  3. Matthew Ratcliffe's avatar
  4. Jamie Kelly's avatar
  5. Daniel Fidel Ferrer's avatar
  6. Ryan Mitchell Wittingslow's avatar
  7. Panu Raatikainen's avatar

This is what the rule of law looks like

Federal judge in West Virginia blasts ICE tactics:

Antiseptic judicial rhetoric cannot do justice to what is happening. Across the interior of the United States, agents of the federal government—masked, anonymous, armed with military weapons, operating from unmarked vehicles, acting without warrants of any kind—are seizing persons for civil immigration violations and imprisoning them without any semblance of due process. The systematic character of this practice and its deliberate elimination of every structural feature that distinguishes constitutional authority from raw force place it beyond the reach of ordinary legal description. It is an assault on the constitutional order. It is what the Fourth Amendment was written to prevent. It is what the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment forbids.

And from the conclusion of the opinion:

An anonymous government is no government at all. It cannot be held accountable. A
masked agent freely uses force without justifying his actions, and the public cannot name him to challenge his conduct. A regime of secret policing has no place in our society. Here, the Government’s power is derived by the People, and the People must be able to identify the Government when it acts to infringe on their liberty. Masks obscure government action and deprive the public of its Fourth Amendment protection

Now the judge will need to put ICE officers and/or administration officials in jail if they don’t comply.

Designed with WordPress