Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Brian Leiter's avatar
  2. Daniel B Dennis's avatar
  3. Natalie Jaworski's avatar
  4. Daniel Kodsi's avatar
  5. Richard Moran's avatar
  6. LFC's avatar

Where U.S. law professors earned their law degree (2008)

The old Leiter Law Rankings site is going offline August 20, so readers who want any of the material there should copy it before then. I am going to post here some of the data that strike me as particularly useful, starting with data on placement in law teaching.

===========

This study is based on the educational credentials of all tenure-track and tenured law faculty as of Spring 2008.  (The underlying data comes from this interesting article.)  This excludes adjuncts, legal writing instructors, and other ‘faculty’ who are not in tenure-stream positions.  But it still covers more than 7,000 faculty at AALS-member law schools. 

Bear in mind that faculty in this sample graduated from law school over a very long period of time, from the 1950s through to nearly the present; schools whose reputations were stronger long ago may do better here than they would in a study confined only to recent hiring, while schools whose reputations have improved over time will likely fare worse here.    Circa 1960, for example, it would have been common to think of Yale, Harvard, and Columbia as clearly the top three law schools, with Penn, Michigan, and perhaps Chicago just a notch below.  Stanford rose to prominence during the 1950s and 1960s, and Chicago’s competitive position improved significantly with the rise of law-and-economics in the 1970s, where it was the primary innovator.  NYU and Georgetown both became far more prominent schools starting in the 1970s as well.  (You can get some sense of the small reputational shifts since the 1970s from this data.)   Columbia slipped out of the “top 3” during the 1960s, Penn slipped out of “the top five” by the 1970s, and Michigan did the same in the 1990s.  Thus, the data below to some extent reflects the large time period covered, which mostly explains the differences (where there are differences) with data focusing on more recent placement in law teaching.

There are two rankings, below.  The first is an attempt to take account of the fact that schools differ quite a bit in the number of students they graduate.  I call it a ‘per capita’ measure, but that’s not what it really is:  it is just an attempt to adjust the results to reflect differences in the pool of graduates each school produces.  (The formula used was to divide the total number of graduates in law teaching by the average number of graduates of the school [rounded to the nearest 25] in recent graduating classes.)  The second ranking is based on the total number of graduates of each school in law teaching.  Gross numbers have some importance too:  alumni in teaching often favor (or at least look favorably upon) graduates of their school, and schools with large numbers of graduates in law teaching are ones whose graduates hiring schools expect to be looking at every year.

Because the ‘per capita’ figure is a rough measure (based on estimates of class size), I’ve created more ties as the numbers became smaller in order to give a more realistic sense of peer clusters. 

I.  Ranking by “Per Capita” Number of Graduates in Law Teaching (“per capita” here really means the total number of graduates divided by the average size of a recent graduating class rounded to the nearest 25)

RankSchool“Per Capita” RateTotal
1Yale University3.56712
2Harvard University1.99993
3University of Chicago1.44288
4Stanford University1.24217
5Columbia University0.82308
 University of Michigan, Ann Arbor0.82309
7University of California, Berkeley0.73201
8University of Pennsylvania0.60152
9New York University0.54245
10Cornell University0.4283
 Duke University0.4691
 Northwestern University0.44111
 University of Virginia0.41154
14Boston University0.2267
 Georgetown University0.27154
 University of California, Los Angeles0.2987
 University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign0.3059
 University of Minnesota, Twin Cities0.2357
 University of Texas, Austin0.25111
 University of Wisconsin, Madison0.3082

II.  Ranking by Total Number of Graduates in Law Teaching

RankSchoolTotal Number of Graduates“Per Capita” Rate
1Harvard University9931.99
2Yale University7123.56
3Columbia University3080.82
 University of Michigan, Ann Arbor3090.82
5University of Chicago2881.44
6New York University2450.54
7Stanford University2171.24
8University of California, Berkeley2010.73
9Georgetown University1540.27
 University of Pennsylvania1520.60
 University of Virginia1540.41
12Northwestern University1110.44
 University of Texas, Austin1110.25
14Duke University910.46
15University of California, Los Angeles870.29
16Cornell University830.42
 University of Wisconsin, Madison820.30
18Boston University670.22
19University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign590.30
 University of Minnesota, Twin Cities570.23

,

One response to “Where U.S. law professors earned their law degree (2008)”

  1. […] Brian Leiter really pulls together some great data. “This study is based on the educational credentials of all tenure-track and tenured law faculty as of Spring 2008.  . . . This excludes adjuncts, legal writing instructors, and other ‘faculty’ who are not in tenure-stream positions.  But it still covers more than 7,000 faculty at AALS-member law schools.”  […]

Designed with WordPress