Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Public R1's avatar
  2. JR's avatar

    …and the GRE doesn’t differentiate at the top as clearly with the new-ish scoring. So it may not be as…

  3. JR's avatar

    The GRE & the SAT are nowhere near as g-loaded as they once were. Neither do they compare to WAIS…

  4. Mike Otsuka's avatar
  5. Russ Winner's avatar
  6. Mike Otsuka's avatar
  7. John Pate's avatar

Law reviews behaving badly

A law professor writes:

I submitted an article to several law reviews (simultaneously as is the norm). A flagship law review at a decent (but not top) school made an offer of publication in Spring 2026. I withdrew the article from consideration at other law reviews after accepting the offer and signing the publication agreement. The journal informed me that they would begin revisions in August 2026.

I have received various emails from the journal over the last several months informing me about progress in looking for sources, assigning editors, etc. Nothing unusual. There were no indications of discontent. The first week of November, the editors told me I would receive proposed revisions shortly. Again, nothing unusual.

Last week, I received an email saying that they were considering revoking the publication agreement if I did not make substantial changes to the article because, in part, they now disagreed with the analysis, could not locate the English language sources, and could not find some of the foreign sources I relied on (some of those sources were in other languages as the article is a comparative piece). I should stress there are no allegations of plagiarism, dishonesty, etc. Moreover, the version of the article they are now objecting to is identical to the one that was accepted for publication. The foreign language sources were in the original version as well.

The student editor who sent me the email threatening to terminate the publication agreement was the same one who had counter-signed the publication agreement and heaped praise on it all along.

More interesting, the letter read like AI. I ran it through Pangram and came up 90% (give or take) authored by AI.

How would you and your readers propose dealing with this situation? Obviously if they could show plagiarism, etc. they could terminate the contract. But I don’t think they can terminate merely because they claim to have changed their minds about the article. Nothing in the contract would allow that.

Comments are open.

,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Designed with WordPress