Interesting lecture by David Chalmers, which runs about 50 minutes or so. I watched the first 35 minutes. A bit crudely, he distinguishes between three “conceptions” or “stances” toward the mind: behavioral, functional, and phenomenological. He focuses on the emotion of “surprise,” and suggests that AI agents satisfy the behavioral criteria for having surprise, they might or might not satisfy the internal functional criteria, and they probably do not have the right phenomenology. One thought that occurred to me is that one might think that to have a mind the phenomenological is indispensable, or that the conjunction of all three is required, and Chalmers may well get to that by the end. But let me invite readers to view the lecture, and then add their thoughts and questions.
My understanding is that whether a biological substrate is required for consciousness at all is extremely controversial. The best article…




Leave a Reply