They are (see earlier posts for an explanation of the ranking):

Group 1 (1) (rounded mean of 5.0)

New York University (5, 5)

Group 2 (2) (rounded mean of 4.5)

Rutgers University, New Brunswick (4.5, 5)

Group 3 (3-5) (rounded mean of 4.0)

City University of New York Graduate Center (4, 4.5)

University of California, Los Angeles (4, 4)

University of Texas, Austin (4, 4)

Evaluators:  Murat Aydede, Kelly Becker, Jose Bermudez, Ned Block, David Braddon-Mitchell, Berit Brogaard, Peter Carruthers, David Chalmers, Jonathan Cohen, John Doris, Peter Godfrey-Smith, Alvin Goldman, Christopher Hill, Henry Jackman, Sean Kelly, Ernest LePore, Barry Loewer, Peter Ludlow, Edouard Machery, Ronald Mallon, Mohan Matthen, Brian McLaughlin, Friederike Moltmann, John Morrison, Bence Nanay, L.A. Paul, Derk Pereboom, Gualtiero Piccinini, Robert Rupert, Susanna Schellenberg, Eric Schwitzgebel, Susanna Siegel, David Sosa, Ernest Sosa, Robert Stainton, Stephen Stich, Daniel Stoljar, Scott Sturgeon, Michael Tye, Ted Warfield, Robert Wilson, Aaron Zimmerman.