Group 1 (1-4) (rounded mean of 4.5)

Harvard University (4.5, 5)

New York University (4.5, 4.5)

University of Michigan, Ann Arbor (4.5, 4.5)

Yale University (4.5, 5)

Group 2 (5-11) (rounded mean of 4.0)

Oxford University (4.5, 4.5)

Princeton University (4, 4)

Rutgers University, New Brunswick (3.5, 3.5)

University of Arizona (4, 4)

University of California, Los Angeles (4, 4)

University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (4, 4)

University of Toronto (4, 4)

Evaluators: Anne Margaret Baxley, Chris Bobonich, Thomas Carson, Roger Crisp, Justin D'Arms, Stephen Darwall, John Doris, James Dreier, Julia Driver, John Martin Fischer, Johann Frick, John Gardner, Gerald Gaus, Brad Hooker, John Horty, Michael Huemer, Terence Irwin, Shelly Kagan, Paul Katsafanas, Michelle Kosch, Ben Laurence, Julia Markovits, Jeff McMahan, Christopher Morris, Colleen Murphy, Dana Nelkin, Alastair Norcross, Michael Otsuka, Carolina Sartorio, David Schmidtz, Mark Schroeder, Russ Shafer-Landau , Hanoch Sheinman, Wayne Sumner, Larry Temkin, John Tasioulas, Peter Vallentyne, Katja Vogt, Allen Wood.