Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. JR's avatar

    …and the GRE doesn’t differentiate at the top as clearly with the new-ish scoring. So it may not be as…

  2. JR's avatar

    The GRE & the SAT are nowhere near as g-loaded as they once were. Neither do they compare to WAIS…

  3. Mike Otsuka's avatar
  4. Russ Winner's avatar
  5. Mike Otsuka's avatar
  6. John Pate's avatar
  7. sahpa's avatar

    > outside a sort of consolidating google effect, and some mathematical achievements, it’s largely just *not* impressive from my perspective…

Graduate admissions in the age of AI, redux

Last January, we had a thread about how to protect the integrity of philosophy graduate admissions given the possibility that applicants might be using LLMs to generate some or all of their writing samples. I thought it would be useful to have a follow-up thread to see what worked and what didn’t. For those new to the discussion, please take a look at the comments on the prior thread–especially this one and this one from faculty involved in admissions.

, ,

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

6 responses to “Graduate admissions in the age of AI, redux”

  1. We did select interviews for a few candidates (lower top 50 PGR program), and while it was time-consuming, we were able to rule out a couple of candidates whose writing samples were strong. In one case, we suspected AI may have been used, in the others, it was just the interviews were so weak as to raise questions about the ability of the applicnat to ultimately be successful in teaching.

  2. I’m curious about a select pool of graduate applicants guest lecturing with their writing sample as the assigned reading for a class or seminar—together with, or in lieu of, an interview. If substituting an actual lecture isn’t desirable, perhaps something like a job talk. The audience, apart from the search committee, would be sort of a third party, and might help stress test a variety of aspects of the writing sample.

    1. Interviews are nerve-wracking enough! You are talking about (usually) very young adults who have virtually no experience presenting or teaching, who must nevertheless present as the ‘most expert in the room’, who will have to navigate questioning from faculty and other advanced undergrad or grad students (the latter of whom, by the way, are usually *harsher*), with some of the highest professional stakes they have ever faced. And it can easily sour the applicant on your department, especially as compared to other departments who treat applicants more like the not-yet-professional philosophers they are. This going well and being productive will be the exception, not the rule. I’m sorry, but it sounds like a terrible idea.

      1. Folks seeking an academic career should generally be looking for opportunities to be involved in professional settings. Perhaps more so in the age of AI, seeking out rejections, valuing real world conversation, and viewing criticisms as opportunities to improve are important for succeeding. Moreover, departments suited to offering the PhD should be able to host interviews that are both engaging and respectful.

      2. As a student of a terminal MA program, I would love to have this opportunity (in this counterfactual situation). It would be such an honor and an exciting challenge, to have the chance to have experts listen to you presenting on something you’ve worked on. (of course, people are different; moreover, an average undergraduate applicant may be less experienced than an average MA student).

  3. Incidentally, oral examinations are very common in Denmark. Though I teach philosophy of science, I work in a Math Department, and math students will typically have a number of oral exams during their bachelors program. These are usually 15 minutes, and involve using the chalkboard. So, it seems that one promising option to sorting those who know what they have “written” and those who really do not is to conduct similar such exercises. I can give more details about these oral exams if anyone is interested.

Designed with WordPress