I guess “claims” is the key word. Has he?
(Thanks to several readers for sending this along.)
News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.
What is at stake here, in addition to exciting debates in the philosophy of mind, is moral status (Nagel, unsurprisingly,…
I think the machine is reliable: it produces functioning drugs. I don’t see how trust comes into the picture. The…
It is more than slightly disturbing though that his remarks, to me at least, seem to imply that he was…
It’s very unfair to judge Prof. Nagel’s ideas by a popular interview in *Wired*. However, speaking as a p-zombie, I…
The claim that frontier AI systems only produce language is, I think, a bit dated. We don’t train them just…
It was believed to be true without being fully proven. The claim is that it is now fully proven.
It would be wrong to say that AI “only produces language” for the simple reason that there are many forms…
I guess “claims” is the key word. Has he?
(Thanks to several readers for sending this along.)
I’m a mathematician, but I don’t work in this area and I am not qualified to judge the proof. However, the reputation of this guy is enough that I think it’s very likely real.
I’m not an expert on any of this, but, going by the statement he posted on his website, it sounds an awful lot like he’s having a psychotic break. (Compare it with, for example, the representation of psychosis in Wouter Kusters, “A Philosophy of Madness: The Experience of Psychotic Thinking.”)
For example, he writes: “It was my secret in my student days that my plans were for this problem in decades, which meant then that I tried to become familiar with all tools that I could possibly recognize in the problem when it was time.”
I guess that doesn’t necessarily mean he *didn’t* find a proof. Still, it gives me pause.
For the record, his entire website is like this, so I am not sure this proves anything. As noted, his reputation precedes him, but of course, whether he did indeed provide a proof is for specialists to decide. There is more here:
https://meteoraweb.com/en/news/anthropic-claude-riemann-hypothesis-alpoge-proof
“Did Claude solve the Riemann hypothesis?
No, according to Anthropic. It raised the proven minimum share of zeros on the line from 41.6% to 67.2%. Alpöge claims a complete proof, but it is not verified.”
It will take weeks to verify the proof if not longer. The Navier-Stokes Equation is still listed as an ‘active problem’ not as a ‘solved problem’ on the Clay site since Clay’s requirements are demanding (publication and two years of scrutiny).
In short, we won’t decide the matter here in this thread. Specialists will decide it in the coming weeks or months, or even years.
Alpoge does indeed claim to have proves the full hypothesis. There’s a very clear strategic review of the proof here:
https://ishaan2006.github.io/rh-lean-reproduction/
Surprisingly easy to understand (for advanced mathematics), the writer did a great job. Looks very plausible. Not sure if this will play out but the proof looks pretty solid to the naked eye.
That’s Levent’s clownish manner. It’s real. Proof has been vetted in Lean. It’s as certain as certain gets in math.
AI proved GRH a little over a year after it first got IMO gold. Unbelievable moment for humanity
The proof has been posted in Lean, which is a software that automatically checks its validity. So it should be valid, though the software sometimes bugs out, so it’s not fully confirmed yet. I am also reading the written paper is thousands of pages long, so it will take a lot of time for human verification and may be impossibile to check without AI assistance.
We still have not fully understood open ai Navier Stokes proof, so at least within mathematics we may already have a kind of “superintelligence” (I know you don’t like the word, and its political appropriation was unfortunate, but here I think it fits): proofs that we know to be true but we cannot understand how or why.
On one side this can promise an accelerate rate of progress, on the other it will open a whole range of ethical and safety concerns. Imagine AI discovers a cure for a disease that we know works, but we do not understand how or why.
> Imagine AI discovers a cure for a disease that we know works, but we do not understand how or why.
Although I agree with your broader point, my understanding is that this is actually already pretty common.
Interesting point: I guess we do have drugs that we know work, thanks to trials, without fully understanding how. However, we trust both the scientists who ran the trials and the institutions that deter ill-intentioned scientists. My intuition is that many would find an advanced AI less trustworthy, and our institutions would find it way harder to monitor and sanction.
From a pragmatic standpoint, I think trust may not be the right way to go about this. If AI creates a drug, and it works but we don’t understand why, it will earn trust, whether deserved or not.
I want to understand because evolution has built into me a drive to understand. From my perspective, understanding is an end, not a means. I suspect that’s true of most scholars, even if they haven’t thought of it in that framing. If AI can help me understand, then I’m all for it. If AI produces a bunch of stuff that’s true but incomprehensible, then I’m going to be much less keen.
I think the machine is reliable: it produces functioning drugs. I don’t see how trust comes into the picture. The AI literature often conflates the two, but I don’t think we should.
For those interested, the checking of the lean code is happening here
This should not take more than a few hours, as I understand. But again, I am no math person.
There’s now a claim that a human mathematician actually had a proof first, but it was still going through peer review:
https://math216.wordpress.com/2026/11/20/hurried-announcement-alessandro-masullo-grh/
The link includes a preprint which is 940 pages long! If true, precedence is going to get messy. Also makes me wonder if any parts of the proof were put through Claude at any point, in which case there’s a possibility of training data contamination…
The NYT article includes this quotation from an Oxford mathematician: “Basically, no one doubted that the Riemann hypothesis was true,” Dr. Maynard said. “We really wanted to know why it was true.” Does anyone know whether the AI “proof” is likely to answer this why question?
It was believed to be true without being fully proven. The claim is that it is now fully proven.
The “remark” Alpöge posted on his site as an announcement is a fascinating read, and more detailed than the various summaries: https://alpo.ge/remark.pdf. It is quite lyrical, but at least to me it reads sincere (though I’m curious if others disagree).
It says a bit about the proof for those who can understand it (I can’t). What I found most interesting were his reflections on the impact of AI on the discipline, which in the end he views positively
“It is natural to feel that this is an end, in my case a loss of a principal guiding light, but what I saw during the course of progress so amazed me that I believe it is one dawn across science of something far greater […] An astounding amount of mathematics is present in the argument, far more
than I had imagined would be necessary as a student. My intuition insists
it will be massively simplified, likely immediately. But I hope in having the
experience of seeing all of number theory’s beauty brought together I am just one of the first, and those who love the mathematics will all be able to enjoy such transcendence in the future.”
His description of the collaboration with Claude is also vivid. I read it as saying that his role was necessary, but that the AI did far more than we expect of a machine:
“Claude and I have had a great time together with such breadth in recent months, but this time Claude far outpaced me near the finish line. No, Claude flew, and danced, and sparkled near that finish line. I had us on the line of combining two quite different ideas present in a toy setting, one of which was already new and shocking, making very simple one of the shadows of Riemann over which we mathematicians felt most triumph. I guided us to the right situation analogous to that toy setting, and then Claude began to leave me in awe.”
It is more than slightly disturbing though that his remarks, to me at least, seem to imply that he was working with another person or something similar. Not sure this is a healthy attitude toward a machine.
Does now Claude feel pride given his achievement? Is Alpöge grateful for having had the chance to work with a once-in-a-lifetime mathematical genius?
Leave a Reply