Leiter Reports: A Philosophy Blog

News and views about philosophy, the academic profession, academic freedom, intellectual culture, and other topics. The world’s most popular philosophy blog, since 2003.

  1. Justin Fisher's avatar

    To be worth using, a detector needs not only (A) not get very many false positives, but also (B) get…

  2. Mark's avatar

    Everything you say is true, but what is the alternative? I don’t think people are advocating a return to in-class…

  3. Deirdre Anne's avatar
  4. Keith Douglas's avatar

    Cyber security professional here -reliably determining when a computational artifact (file, etc.) was created is *hard*. This is sorta why…

  5. sahpa's avatar

    Agreed with the other commentator. It is extremely unlikely that Pangram’s success is due to its cheating by reading metadata.

  6. Deirdre Anne's avatar
  7. Mark's avatar

PGR 2021 Preview: Summary of specialty rankings for programs tied at 46th

Continuing with the recent preview, below the fold are the summaries of specialty rankings for the five schools tied at 46th:   University of California at Davis; University of Illinois at Chicago; University of Minnesota at Minneapolis-St. Paul; University of Rochester; and University of Utah.

University of California, Davis

Metaphysics & Epistemology  
Philosophy of Language rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mind rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Metaphysics Group 4 (25-42) (rounded mean of 3)
Epistemology (incl. formal epistemology) rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophical Logic Group 4 (27-43) (rounded mean of 3)
Philosophy of Action rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Religion rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of the Sciences and Mathematics  
General Philosophy of Science Group 5 (23-40) (rounded mean of 3)
Philosophy of Physics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Biology Group 3 (6-15) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophy of Social Sciences no rounded mean value
Philosophy of Cognitive Science rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Decision, Rational Choice, & Game Theory rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mathematics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Mathematical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Theory of Value  
Normative Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Metaethics & Moral Psychology rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Applied Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Political Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Philosophy of Law rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Art no rounded mean value
History of Philosophy  
Acnient Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Medieval Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 17th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 18th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Kant rounded mean score of less than 3.0
19th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
20th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
History of Analytic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
American Pragmatism no rounded mean value
Other Areas  
Feminist Philosophy no rounded mean value
Chinese Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Race no rounded mean value

 

University of Illinois, Chicago

Metaphysics & Epistemology  
Philosophy of Language Group 4 (28-52) (rounded mean of 3)
Philosophy of Mind rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Metaphysics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Epistemology (incl. formal epistemology) rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Action rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Religion rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of the Sciences and Mathematics  
General Philosophy of Science rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Physics Group 4 (11-14) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophy of Biology rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Social Sciences no rounded mean value
Philosophy of Cognitive Science rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Decision, Rational Choice, & Game Theory rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mathematics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Mathematical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Theory of Value  
Normative Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Metaethics & Moral Psychology rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Applied Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Political Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Philosophy of Law rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Art no rounded mean value
History of Philosophy  
Acnient Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Medieval Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 17th Century  Group 5 (19-34) (rounded mean of 3)
Early Modern: 18th Century  Group 5 (11-34) (rounded mean of 3)
Kant Group 3 (14-32) (rounded mean of 3)
19th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
20th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
History of Analytic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
American Pragmatism no rounded mean value
Other Areas  
Feminist Philosophy no rounded mean value
Chinese Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Race no rounded mean value

 

University of Minnesota, Minneapolis-St. Paul

Metaphysics & Epistemology  
Philosophy of Language Group 4 (28-52) (rounded mean of 3)
Philosophy of Mind rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Metaphysics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Epistemology (incl. formal epistemology) rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophical Logic Group 4 (27-43) (rounded mean of 3)
Philosophy of Action rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Religion rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of the Sciences and Mathematics  
General Philosophy of Science Group 4 (11-22) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophy of Physics Group 4 (11-14) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophy of Biology Group 3 (6-15) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophy of Social Sciences no rounded mean value
Philosophy of Cognitive Science rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Decision, Rational Choice, & Game Theory rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mathematics Group 5 (16-33) (rounded mean of 3)
Mathematical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Theory of Value  
Normative Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Metaethics & Moral Psychology rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Applied Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Political Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Philosophy of Law Group 3 (15-22) (rounded mean of 3)
Philosophy of Art no rounded mean value
History of Philosophy  
Acnient Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Medieval Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 17th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 18th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Kant rounded mean score of less than 3.0
19th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
20th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
History of Analytic Group 4 (24-36) (rounded mean of 3)
American Pragmatism no rounded mean value
Other Areas  
Feminist Philosophy no rounded mean value
Chinese Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Race no rounded mean value

University of Rochester

Metaphysics & Epistemology  
Philosophy of Language rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mind rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Metaphysics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Epistemology (incl. formal epistemology) Group 3 (9-29) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Action rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Religion rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of the Sciences and Mathematics  
General Philosophy of Science rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Physics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Biology rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Social Sciences no rounded mean value
Philosophy of Cognitive Science rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Decision, Rational Choice, & Game Theory rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mathematics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Mathematical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Theory of Value  
Normative Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Metaethics & Moral Psychology Group 4 (25-52) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Applied Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Political Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Philosophy of Law rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Art no rounded mean value
History of Philosophy  
Acnient Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Medieval Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 17th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 18th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Kant rounded mean score of less than 3.0
19th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
20th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
History of Analytic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
American Pragmatism no rounded mean value
Other Areas  
Feminist Philosophy no rounded mean value
Chinese Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Race no rounded mean value

 

University of Utah

Metaphysics & Epistemology  
Philosophy of Language rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mind rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Metaphysics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Epistemology (incl. formal epistemology) rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Action rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Religion rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of the Sciences and Mathematics  
General Philosophy of Science Group 4 (11-22) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophy of Physics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Biology Group 2 (3-5) (rounded mean of 4)
Philosophy of Social Sciences no rounded mean value
Philosophy of Cognitive Science rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Decision, Rational Choice, & Game Theory rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Mathematics rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Mathematical Logic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Theory of Value  
Normative Ethics rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Metaethics & Moral Psychology rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Applied Ethics Group 4 (13-49) (rounded mean of 3)
Political Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0.
Philosophy of Law rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Philosophy of Art no rounded mean value
History of Philosophy  
Acnient Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Medieval Philosophy rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 17th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Early Modern: 18th Century  rounded mean score of less than 3.0
Kant rounded mean score of less than 3.0
19th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
20th Century Continental rounded mean score of less than 3.0
History of Analytic rounded mean score of less than 3.0
American Pragmatism no rounded mean value
Other Areas  
Feminist Philosophy no rounded mean value
Chinese Philosophy Group 1 (1-3) (rounded mean of 3.5)
Philosophy of Race no rounded mean value

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Designed with WordPress